Showing posts with label intellectual. Show all posts
Showing posts with label intellectual. Show all posts

Sunday, 6 April 2014

Arbitration of Intellectual Property and Technology Disputes

Jane Lambert











Arbitration is a method of resolving disputes. It arises out of an agreement between two or more parties to refer an existing or any future dispute that may arise to a third party known as the arbitratior ("arbiter" in Scotland) who will decide the case on its merits after considering evidence and arguments. The arbitrator's decision, which is known as an award, is enforced in England and Wales in the same way as a judgment (see s.66 (1) of the Arbitration Act 1996).  Her Majesty's Government is party to an international agreement to which most countries in the world belong known as the Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (New York, 1958) (the "New York Convention") whereby each party agrees to enforce in its territories arbitration awards made in accordance with its provisions.

What are the Advantages of Arbitration?
Because the arbitration arises out of an agreement between the parties, it is they rather than an outside agency such as HM Courts and Tribunals Service who control the process. That means that the dispute can be determined in a manner and at a time of the parties' choosing by a tribunal of their choice whose competence, experience and impartiality they can trust rather than by the judge to whom their case is allocated who may or may not have relevant knowledge and experience who will apply rules of procedure and evidence that may not be relevant when the case comes into his or her list. Arbitration can therefore be quicker, cheaper and less formal than litigation and render better justice though much will depend on the terms of the arbitration agreement and the skills, knowledge and experience of the arbitrator. In most cases arbitrations are conducted in private so that nobody but the persons involved in the process hear damaging or embarrassing disclosures. That often makes it easier for them to maintain or renew a business relationship once the dispute is resolved.

And the Disadvantages?
These are largely the converse of the advantages and usually result from a badly drawn up agreement or an incompetent, inexperienced or less than impartial arbitrator.  The costs and delay can be greater than the parties would have been incurred had they gone to court and the decision may be less than fair or wrong in law. In nearly every case the parties have to pay a fee to the arbitrator and hire the room in which the arbitration takes place and the office equipment, stationery and other consumables that the arbitrator uses. The privacy of the arbitration may hide from the public facts and matters that should be made known and indeed may remove one of the incentives to early settlement. Often the remedies available to the arbitrator and the opportunities to challenge an award are limited.

What Sort of Cases are suitable for Arbitration?
Generally these are cases in which the parties have agreed to resolve any disputes that may arise by arbitration at the time they made their contract. One such agreement might be for the supply of computer equipment or services where the supplier is in a developed country and the customer may be a government department in a less developed country where the judges are not known for their independence of the executive. Another might be a licensing agreement where the parties have done good business with each other before and expect to do so again. However, the parties can agree to refer an existing dispute to arbitration. One instance in which they may decide to do so is after they have exchanged letters of claim and response in accordance with the Practice Direction - Pre-Action Conduct, seen each other's evidence, tried unsuccessfully to resolve their dispute through negotiation. They may try arbitration because they do not want to go to court since the case turns on issues of law or fact that could be solved quickly, cheaply and easily by an experienced specialist arbitraior.

What Sort of Cases are unsuitable?
These are generally cases where the parties do not trust each other (which will include most infringement actions) where one of the parties wants an injunction to restrain the other side from damaging its interests.  Having said that s.48 (5) of the Arbitration Act 1996 confers upon an arbitrator (subject to any agreement to the contrary) the same powers as a judge:
"(a) to order a party to do or refrain from doing anything;
(b) to order specific performance of a contract (other than a contract relating to land);
(c) to order the rectification, setting aside or cancellation of a deed or other document."
 Moreover the civil courts have power under s.44 (2) (e) to grant injunctions in support of an arbitration. It should also be noted that arbitration is a procedure that can be used at any time. There is no reason why one part of the dispute cannot be resolved by litigation, negotiation or mediation and another by arbitration. Intellectual property disputes are usually determined in two phases: the first stage being to decide liability and the second the pecuniary remedy. The taking of an account of profits or an inquiry as to damages is a technical matter involving forensic accountants that could often be conducted more cheaply and quickly by an arbitrator.

Where to find an Arbitrator
Moat arbitrators in the UK are trained and accredited by the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators ("CIArb") which keeps a searchable database of members with particulars of their qualifications. An international panel of arbitrators, mediators and other dispute resolution providers who specialize in intellectual property and technology is maintained by WIPO ("World Intellectual Property Organization") the UN agency for intellectual property. As you can see, I am a member of that panel.  And then there are us (see "Our IP and Technology Dispute Resolution Team" 28 Dec 2013 4-5 IP). Our members include Professor Louis Harms, the former Deputy President of the Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa, Thomas Dillon who was a senior in-house legal advisor to the trade association of the US film and TV industry as well as me.

How to Appoint an Arbitrator
If you have an arbitration agreement it will probably set out a procedure for appointing an arbitrator. Typical language will be
"Any dispute or difference shall be referred to arbitration before a single arbitrator agreed by the parties of in default of agreement within 28 days appointed by the Chair for the time being of the Bar of England and Wales."
The usual procedure is for the parties to exchange lists of names and curricula vitarum. If the same name appears on both lists he or she is likely to become the arbitrator. If the parties cannot agree the Chair of the Bar or other appointing party will select a suitable candidate from his or her list. Once the arbitrator has been agreed or appointed the parties may enter a supplemental agreement within the arbitrator covering such matters as his or her fees and the date, time and place of the arbitration.

What happens next?
That depends on the terms of the arbitration agreement and the rules that the parties have agreed to adopt. The arbitration may be conducted entirely in writing, orally or partly orally and partly in writing. Usually, the complainant has to send a statement of case to the arbitrator and the other side to which the respondent has to reply within a specified time. Such statements of case are very much like the particulars of claim and defence in civil litigation. After statements of case have been exchanged or indeed at any other time the arbitrator may invite the parties to a case management meeting or he or she may give directions on his or her own initiative in writing. In some cases, disclosure of documents and the exchange of witness statements and experts' reports may be ordered. In other cases, the arbitrator may order documents to be attached to the statements of case or witness statements. If the parties agree, or the arbitrator decides, that witnesses' testimony needs to be tested by cross-examination he or she will order a hearing which will be conducted very much like a trial. Arbitrators have power under s.38 (5) of the Arbitration Act 1996 to examine witnesses on oath and the civil courts have power under s.43 to compel the attendance of witnesses. Once the arbitrator has considered the evidence and arguments he or she will draft the award. The arbitrator has power under s.56 to without publication of his award until his or her fees have been paid. If as is frequently the case the person paying the arbitrator is the party who succeeds in the arbitration the arbitrator's fee (or at any rate a portion of it) can usually be recovered from the other side. The circumstances in which an award can be challenged are set out in s.67 and s.68 or they may be provision for an appeal or challenge in the rules or arbitration agreement.

Do you want to learn more?
if you happen to be anywhere near Sheffield tomorrow evening you can hear me mention arbitration as well as other forms of ADR in my talk to Sheffield Inventors' Group at the Business and IP Centre at Central Library at 18:00 tomorrow (see "Holding your Own - How to stop others from ripping you off if you are a Private Inventor" 5 April 2014 IP Yorks). If there is sufficient demand I will hold a seminar on ADR of IP disputes at chambers or alternatively a webinar which will of course carry SRA, BSB and IPReg points. If you are interested in attending such an event please call me on 020 7404 5252 or message me through my contact form. You can also tweet me, write on my wall or get in touch through Linkedin, G+ or Xing.  If you need someone to sit as an arbitrator, to represent you before an arbitration, to draft an arbitration agreement or otherwise advise in relation to an arbitration please call our clerks on +44 (0)20 7404 5252 or complete their enquiry form.

Further Reading

Jane Lambert "Our IP and Technology Dispute Resolution Team" 28 Dec 2014 4-5 IP

Thursday, 10 October 2013

Introduction to Design Law

British Leyland v Armstrong Patents - the appeal over exhaust pipes that changed
British design law
Photo Wilipedia


























Jane Lambert

In everyday language the word design is used in two senses.  We talk of designer jeans and furnishings but also of engine and web design. When used in the first sense the word refers to the appearance of things. In the second sense the word refers to the shape or configuration of an article often so that the article can perform a function.  We call designs in the first category decorative, ornamental or even aesthetic designs and those in the second category functional designs. Most legal systems including ours protect decorative and functional designs in different ways.

That has not always been the case.  Until the 31 July 1989 most functional as well as decorative designs were protected by copyright in the United Kingdom and many Commonwealth countries. Theoretically s.3 of the Copyright Act 1956 did not protect designs as such, but the engineering or production drawing from which an object (which could be a machine or a component for a machine) was manufactured. So long as they were not copied wholly from an antecedent work, such drawings qualified for copyright protection as original artistic works. Copyright subsisted in those drawings for a very long time, namely the life of the author plus 50 years.  If the object that had been made to the drawing had been copied then so too had the drawing, albeit indirectly, The sanctions for copyright infringement were draconian.  In addition to injunctions. orders for delivery up and compensatory and additional damages each infringing copy was deemed to belong to the copyright owner and an infringer who had sold such such copies also had to pay damages for conversion.

The difficulties of protecting functional designs by artistic copyright were exposed by the decision of the House of Lords in British Leyland Motor Corporation and Others v Armstrong Patents Company Ltd and Others [1986] 2 WLR 400, [1986] UKHL 7, [1986] RPC 279, (1986) 5 Tr LR 97, [1986] FSR 221, [1986] 1 All ER 850, [1986] ECC 534, [1986] AC 577 where a motor manufacturer relied on copyright to prevent a replacement parts manufacturer from making exhaust pipes for its motor cars.  In order to prevent monopolization of the after-market the law lords developed a non-statutory exemption to the Copyright Act 1956 conferring a right to repair.

Shortly after that appeal Parliament passed the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 which came into effect on 1 Aug 1989.   S.51 (1) of that Act provided:
"It is not an infringement of any copyright in a design document or model recording or embodying a design for anything other than an artistic work or a typeface to make an article to the design or to copy an article made to the design."
At a stroke that provision brought to an end copyright protection of functional designs.   However, Part III of the same Act introduced a new intellectual property right known as design right which subsisted in original designs.   "Design" for these purposes was defined by s.213 (1) of the 1988 Act as:
"the design of any aspect of the shape or configuration (whether internal or external) of the whole or part of an article."
This right could be infringed by making articles to the design and making articles to the design was defined by s.226 (2) as
"copying the design so as to produce articles exactly or substantially to that design, and references in this Part to making articles to a design shall be construed accordingly."
Although design right is very similar to copyright there are a number of important differences.  First, the term is very much shorter:
  • up to 10 years from the date upon which articles made to the design are first offered for sale or hire; or
  • up to 15 years from the date the design was first recorded in a design document or prototype if articles made to the designer are not offered for sale or hire in the first 5 years of that period.
Secondly, in the last 5 years of the term anyone in the world including an infringer can apply for a licence to do any act that would otherwise infringe design right as of right.  Thirdly, as very few countries adopted similar legislation the citizens of very few countries outside the EU are entitled to claim design right protection for their functional designs.

S.213 (3) (c) of the Act excludes "surface decoration" from the definition of "design" for the purposes of Part III.  Thus, the only way of protecting fabrics, wall coverings and the like remains copyright.

Although decorative designs were protected by copyright until 1989 it was also possible to register them with the Intellectual Property Office ("IPO") for up to 5 renewable periods of 5 years each under the Registered Designs Act 1949.  As originally enacted, registration conferred a monopoly known as "design copyright" for new or original designs and design for that purpose meant "features of shape, configuration, pattern or ornament applied to an article by any industrial process or means, being features which in the finished article appeal to and are judged solely by the eye."  The 1949 Act is still in force but it has been overhauled twice: first by Part IV of, and Sched. 4 to, the Copyright, Designs Act 1988 and, more recently, by the Registered Designs Regulations 2001 which implement Directive 98/71/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 October 1998 on the legal protection of designs.  The IPO has published a useful unofficial consolidation of the Registered Designs Act 1949 as amended.  Under the amended Act designs may be registered if they are new and have individual character.

Designs that are new and have individual character may also be registered at OHIM (Office of Harmonization in the Internal Market (Trade Marks and Designs) for the EU (including the UK) under the Community Designs Regulation (Council Regulation (EC) No 6/2002 of 12 December 2001 on Community designs (OJ EC No L 3 of 5.1.2002, p. 1). Designs registered with OHIM under this Regulation are known as registered Community designs. 

The Community Designs Regulation also establishes a new intellectual property right for the whole EU known as unregistered Community design.   Designs that are new and have individual character and could therefore be registered with OHIM as registered Community designs or indeed with the IPO under the Registered Designs Act 1949 are protected from copying for up to 3 years from the time they are first made available within the EU.  This unregistered right is particularly useful for the fashion, toy and other industries where the shelf life of a design is very short.

To recap there are five ways of protecting designs in  the UK:
  • functional and indeed some ornamental designs are protected in the UK alone by design right pursuant to Part III of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988;
  • artwork recording designs of fabrics, wall coverings and other surface decoration continues to be protected by copyright;
  • designs that are new and have individual character can be protected in the UK by registration under the Registered Designs Act 1949;
  • such designs could also be protected throughout the whole EU by registration as registered Community designs; and
  • such designs can also be protected for up to 3 years throughout the EU without registration as unregistered Community designs.
Design law is likely to be overhauled yet again by the Intellectual Property Bill which is now with the House of Commons. For an overview and commentary on the Bill as it stood in May see my article on The Intellectual Property Bill 28 May 2013 NIPC Law.

Should you wish to learn more about design law, I shall be leading a seminar on Creative Output - Copyright and Related Rights on 30 Oct 2013 at 4-5 Gray's Inn Square between 14:00 and 16:00.  If you want to come you can register on-line through our Eventrbrite site.  The event is free but places are filling up so it is essential to book.   If you want to discuss this article or any aspect of design law call me on 020 7404 5252 during office hours or get in touch through my contact form.

Related Articles

Jane Lambert   "What is IP? Why do Folk want it? How do they get it? How to learn more?" 20 Aug 2013 IP South East

Saturday, 6 July 2013

Choosing the Right Kind of IP - Five Top Tips














Jane Lambert

What is Intellectual Property?
As I said in my presentation, "Introduction to Intellectual Property", which you can download here, intellectual property ("IP") is "the collective term for the bundle of laws that protect investment in intellectual assets. ("IA"). In the same presentation I defined intellectual assets as the brands, designs, technology or works of art and literature that give one business a competitive advantage over all others.

Different Ways of protecting IA
Most of those IA can be protected in a variety of ways. For example, you can apply for a patent for a new product or process but you have to the your invention to the world in sufficient detail for anyone with th right skills and experience to make it. That's fine if you get a patent, if t is valid and if you can afford to enforce it but these are three very big ifs,  Alternatively, you can rely on some other IP right such as the the law of confidence, unregistered design right or in some cases confidence.

Patenting does not come cheap.  According to research that had been commissioned by the European Patent Office in 2004 the cost of a typical European patent over 10 years amounted to €32,000. Since a fair proportion  of the patents on the register are never worked, and of those that are worked only a tiny number make serious money for their proprietors, patenting an invention can often be a complete waste of money.

Of course if you really have invented something like Emerson's better mousetrap and the world really is beating a path to your door, then it would be a shame not to have patented the invention.

Five Top Tips
So how do you find the right king of IP protection for your IA? The answer is that it is very difficult but here are some useful tips:

  1. When you write your business plan for your business or project, try to identify the income streams for the planning period. Consider the potential threats to those income streams during that period and then think of some possible countermeasures. In most cases, the threats will be commercial rather than legal and most of the countermeasures will be commercial too. If, however, one of those threats is imitation of your product or process by a competitor then maybe you need some kind of legal protection. The appropriate legal protection will depend on the nature of the threat. If your competitor is likely to copy the shape or configuration of your product then maybe some kind of design protection is required. If it is the mechanism of the product that is likely to be imitated then perhaps you need to consider unregistered design right or even patents.
  2. An IP right ("IPR") is essentially a title to bring a lawsuit. Except for a handful of infringements that are also criminal offences it is up to the IPR owner to enforce his rights in the civil courts.  Though the cost of IP enforcement has come down considerably with reforms to the Patents County Court litigation is still expensive.  It is important to ensure that you can enforce your IPR which in most cases means taking out specialist IP insurance (see my articles "Intellectual Property Litigation - the Funding Options"  23 April 2013 NIPC Law and "IP Insurance Five Years on" 23 Oct 2010 Inventors Club).
  3. You do not have to protect your IA everywhere. If you have no market in Ruritania and nobody is capable of making the product for export there then you do no need patent protection in that state.
  4. Make sure that you get the right kind of professional advice for each type of problem. For instance, if you want to apply for a patent you should consult a patent agent (aka patent attorney).  Although it is easier to apply for a registered design or trade mark and many businessmen and women make successful applications without an agent that I would still advise you to seek professional help. Attorneys are specially trained in IP law and practice. Their professions are regulated by the IP Regulation Board. They carry professional indemnity insurance if things go wrong.  If you do not already have a patent or trade mark attorney then we can introduce you to one with whom we have worked well. Alternatively, the Chartered Institute of Patent Attorneys and the Institute of Trade Mark Attorneys have searchable databases on their websites.
  5. Before you spend any money on patenting, trade marking or registering a design it is a good idea to devise an IP strategy and perhaps talking to an IP strategist.  IP strategists are a rapidly developing profession in its own right whose practitioners can be members of any of the IP professions (see "What is IP Strategy" 9 Jan 211).
Further Information
If you want to discuss any of these points in greater detail, give me a ring on 020 7404 5252 or fill out my contact form.